This show looks like the BIGGEST load of complete and utter shit. I am actually really angry about it because I have had not one but at least four people I know comment to me about how they are watching it and then relaying his advice to me. I can see why it will be popular and I can see why people are excited, everyone is always looking for the quick fix. I am so tired of people like this guy and even networks like TLC exploiting people who do have a real health problem with being overweight or obese. It offers a set-up for failure by creating unreal expectations and giving bad information. Let me break it down:
1) The title of the show.
Only YOU can make YOURSELF thin. No one and no little trick can do it for you. Losing weight is also about much more than being “thin”, it’s about being healthy and strong. Most people at their idea weight will NOT look like Nicole Richie or Victoria Beckham. And, that is important because being thin with no muscle tone is pretty lazy, just as lazy and being overweight with no muscle tone. I do not like the fact that it draws up a fantasy image in most peoples heads of what they will look like as a skinny person. Instead of focusing on how much more active they will be, how their life will change for the better, how they will sleep better and be happier and none of it has to do with what they see looking back at them in the mirror, it has to do with how physically fit they are. So, that is the other thing- why in the HALE does this not include at least moderate exercise?! There is no way you can be thin and healthy without it. No freaking way. And yes it sucks at first and yes its hard to squeeze in time but there should be no excuses. It is your life we are talking about here, there is always time to make sure your body is conditioned. Some people learn to love exercise and others always dislike it but it’s something that has to be done. We take out the garbage so the house doesn’t stink, right? Same thing. It might be a chore but it’s necessary.
2) Buy things you LIKE to eat just don’t eat too much of it. When Mr. McKenna thinks of low-fat food he thinks “chemical rubbish”.
Argh! There is a big difference between a full plate of portioned out protein, carbs and fat than a bowl of mac n cheese. The entire plate full is about 400 calories, the other is nearly 1200 and much less food for you to eat and basically all carbs and fat so you are likely to not feel satisfied. Protein is what helps us feel full. No matter how many times Paul tells people they just need to slow down, savor, chew each bite 340984589 times, it will not help. Food will turn to absolute icky mush in your mouth if you chew too much. By all means, slow it down a bit but no need to get crazy with it that is what the stomach is for, breaking down food. And NO you can’t just eat what you want all the time because it’s probably not healthy. And, making a choice like wheat instead of white doesn’t affect taste. Neither does buying cheese made with less milk fat than full fat cheeses. It doesn’t taste different and it’s better for you which seems like a no brainer. All you need to do is look at the labels and learn what the content means(I will discuss this in detail soon). I do agree that some diet foods do taste like ass and are way beyond something that anyone would keep eating forever to actually achieve the lifestyle change needed for permanent weightloss but you’ll learn to pick those out. Sometimes low-fat sour cream is better than fat-free sour cream. And better than that is greek yogurt which tastes the same and is less calories than both of those just as an example. With his suggestions, you might lose a few pounds by cutting down your portions of unhealthy food with no exercise but it’ll get you nowhere fast.
3) Don’t weigh yourself daily, only do it weekly.
This to me isn’t the most result producing idea. Yes, it does make sense if you have a regular scale that only shows the weight number(assuming you calibrate it at least once a month!) because when you gain muscle and lose fat it might show as a gain so each week is a better estimate. However, I would suggest getting a scale like the Tanita I have that shows your weight, body fat percentage, muscle lbs, water percentage, visceral fat(fat around inner organs and stomach) and bone desity. This way you can match your new recipes to if you gained fat and lost muscle or if you lost fat or if you just stayed the same weight and fat percentage but gained muscle. It lets you know if you are eating too little( you will lose muscle and fat which is Bad Bad Bad because the more muscle you have the more fat your burn). Or, if you are eating too much. I would say this is an investment worth making because it is your health afterall and you need to know what works for you daily.
There is so much more to say but basically- don’t watch this stuff. Do you really want to support the diet industry and it’s billions of dollars a year that they take out of your pocket by boosting your confidence and then not delivering results? Wouldn’t you rather change your life for yourself and without any fad or technique? You’d be better serviced by going to the gym or curves for half an hour or even reading on google about carbs, fats, proteins, sodium, etc. In addition, you can read my new blog as well(it’s coming soon) because I’m a normal person going through this now and I can hopefully be of some help with real topics and real photos/ingredients of meals i actually make.